LaSalle and Peru were once on their way to becoming great cities of the Midwest, but for some reason they never quite made it...
Showing posts with label History. Show all posts
Showing posts with label History. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 13, 2012

Transportation Patterns and Business Districts

I noticed a basic pattern in urban development that early transportation innovations often complemented and reinforced previous transportation patterns. More recent transportation innovations are often quite the opposite, and seek to undermine or rearrange previous transportation patterns. I made a series of maps to show what I mean:

The first era is the era of water transportation. There was very little infrastructure in the Midwest in the mid 1800s and it was convenient to use water as easy transportation. The map below shows the business districts as identified by the 1926 Sanborn maps: Downtown LaSalle, LaSalle's 8th Street Business District, Peru's 4th Street Business District, Water Street Business District, and Oglesby's Downtown. This is a bit anachronistic since Oglesby was not founded in the days of water transport, but I threw it in to make mapping easier and to add reference. Peru was founded on the Illinois River and LaSalle, along the Illinois and Michigan Canal. Both received large volumes of steam boat traffic. 
 
Very quickly after came railroads, which effectively competed with the canal enough to shut it down. In this case the Rock Island Railroad was completely parallel to the canal. Railroads often followed old water routes due to the ease of transferring right of way along waterfronts and due to the gentle grades that locomotives need. The blue dots on the map represent stations, where the majority of passenger and less specialized freight would have entered and left the network.

Roads systems back then were very poor and largely unimproved. Major roads often supplemented the existing railroad and water systems. Thus many run perpendicular to the waterways and run through and radiate out of the business districts. Roads would connect people to where they wanted to go, this necessitated going through the business districts. Bridges were especially important, since they funneled traffic into the business districts. They replaced ferries, which were not limited by engineering in where they could start or stop.

The roads below are green and the data was taken from a 1922 highway map of Illinois. It is interesting that a fair portion of these roads no longer exist in an unbroken form. They were not roads with limited stops, like today's highways, they had very little traffic control. They speeds used by horses and men were not high enough to warrant much control except in especially dense traffic situations within the cities. These highways were really just marked trails. The innovation to label highways came to help travelers find their way across the nation.
The Rail era crested with rails in the streets. Streetcars mainly transported passengers within cities. They traveled at lows speeds of about 6 to 8 mph so that passengers could run and hop on. Streetcars were often built to connect speculative subdivisions to the business district. Interurbans were electric railways that transported passengers between cities. The streetcars and interurban systems are in red on the map beneath.
As automobiles grew in popularity, traffic signals came into being and roads were prioritized into feeders and arterials. In the 50's onward the idea came to try to relieve traffic in town by bypassing the town. Interstates and limited access highways were brought about. Old highways were routed to the edges of the business districts instead of through. Eventually automobiles and regulations ended passenger rail leaving Water Street commercially inactive. Eventually it was rezoned as industrial. Oglesby's downtown is more off the beaten path as well. Commerce and industry now hugs the Interstate systems. The beige blobs beneath are what would probably be considered the modern equivalent of downtowns.
Perhaps in the future, downtown style business districts will go the way of horses, passenger rail, steamboat, and canal packet as the infrastructure that sustained them is eroded:
...but I doubt it.

These maps show the assembly of people, traffic, and life into the business district and the reinforcing pattern created by early transportation systems. Modern transportation systems dealing with larger vehicles are much more concerned with providing larger capacity and prefer to disassemble the urban environment, as they divert people to different, further locations, in order to keep the old roads from congestion. And they succeed, perhaps too well, creating congestion in new places, while deadening the old. There is relatively little change in the total amount of activity on the whole, but it is taking place in a much more distributed and disassembled environment than in eras past. 

Sunday, January 22, 2012

Demographic History



I was exploring old Census Data and constructed the following graphs and tables. All data is for the municipalities and not the townships.
LaSalle peaks in 1930 with 13,149 residents.
Peru peaks in 1970 with 11,772 residents.
The greatest total population of the combined LaSalle-Peru was in 1970 with 22,508 residents. 

I've highlighted all growth rates greater than 10% in red and all growth rates less than zero in yellow; completely arbitrary colours that might have been better chosen.

Urbanization of Downtown LaSalle

Let's take a look at the development of LaSalle through history, specifically block 120. This block is bounded by Marquette (top), First (right), Gooding, (bottom) and Second Streets (left).
1888
The earliest map I could find is 1888, some forty years after LaSalle's founding. First street is obviously the most valued street, since that is where buildings are most dense. Decent building densities are also found on the streets radiating from First Street. Was Gooding Street really called Goodling, or is that just an error on the part of the mapmakers? I find it amazing that there are approximately three buildings on each platted lot. The LaSalle Hotel appears to be above several shops. All these pieces of evidence point towards an urbanizing process.
 1898 
Values on Marquette Street rise in 1898, possibly due to the increased traffic across the Shippingsport

Tuesday, January 10, 2012

Land Speculation and Dreams of Metropolis

Thompson Canal Survey Map of 1829
In 1830 a survey for the Illinois and Michigan Canal was made, prompted by the success of the Erie Canal completed in 1825. Since regular steamboat traffic was possible only up to the rapids at Starved Rock, the canal's southern terminus would have to be downstream from there. But where exactly?

Land speculation was a growing phenomenon in the Northwest Territory (today's Midwest), to the point that some humorously claimed that the entire territory from the Appalachians to the Mississippi was platted as a city. Think of the number of towns in LaSalle township alone that never became incorporated as their own municipalities: Rockwell, Piety Hill, Shippingsport, Crocketville, Jonesville, and Deer Park/Black Hollow.

All of the speculated towns back then dreamed of being cities. A description of Rockwell by the Rockwell Land Company highlights the features of canal, steamboat access, railroads, mill sites, school houses, stores, warehouses, and a ban on "ardent spirits." Famously Cairo, IL, was drawn as a bustling metropolis by its advertisers, misleading a few settlers into moving in to find only a few cabins. Urbanism was a goal and people were attracted by it. People saw wealth in being at the crossroads of commerce and industry.

Speculation as to the intermodal point at the terminus of the Illinois and Michigan Canal attracted heavy investment into gambling on that location. That location was deemed to be valuable as a center of commerce. The two ends of the canal were believed to be the location of the two gateway cities to the Midwest. All raw goods from the Midwest to the markets on the East would have to pass through the canal as well as all processed goods from the East on their way to the West.

Thus began the competition for the imagined future granted by the canal. Sometime before 1832, the town of Science was platted south of today's North Utica. Since there was already a small population, there was hope that the canal would meet the river there. In 1835 Peru and Rockwell were platted by speculators from the East. Rockwell was placed by Dixwell Lathrop, beleiving that the canal would utilize Split Rock Lake. Peru thought that it would terminate closer to slightly higher ground. Despite all this, in 1836, LaSalle was platted by the Canal Commission as the terminus of the canal.
Crudely Drawn Diagram showing the locations of potential termini
On July 1836 in Bridgeport, the Illinois and Michigan Canal broke ground to be completed in 1848.

Though many speculators plats vied for regional supremacy throughout the United States, only a few made it, leaving behind a great many sleepy little towns dreaming of the day when they will have their chance again.

Sources: LaSalle County Lore, LaSalle County: the Rivers and the Prairies, City of LaSalle Sesquicentennial, 1892 Plat Book: LaSalle County, Cities of the Mississippi: Nineteenth Century Images of Urban Development.