LaSalle and Peru were once on their way to becoming great cities of the Midwest, but for some reason they never quite made it...
Showing posts with label Jane Jacobs. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jane Jacobs. Show all posts

Sunday, August 5, 2012

Jane Jacobs: Some Myths About Diversity

I cobbled this post out of common objections that Jane Jacobs refuted. It's not really a complete post, but since I haven't worked on it for a while, I'm just going to post it.

Mixed Uses Look Ugly

Sameness looks monotonous, which, though orderly, is dull. She claims that there is still a desire among homogenous uses to appear different, and that it can manifest itself in weird contrived features. So homogenous uses are either depressingly monotonous or "vulgarly chaotic." Admittedly I find this difficult to defend from either side, but I think her point is that mixed uses are not inherently ugly, and that homogenous uses are not inherently beautiful.


Mixed Uses Cause Traffic Congestion
"Traffic Congestion is caused by vehicles, not by people in themselves." 
I could just say, "Look at Peru's strip," where single uses cause traffic congestion. Nobody can really get there, except by car (I've walked it a few times, but it is not fun). The old downtowns are easily reachable by foot or bike. Homogenous uses create a need for automobiles by increasing the distance to go in order to reach other uses. Human lives are so entwined between uses that their physical separation does not make sense. Trips would be shorter with mixed uses. People might even be able to walk. Walking takes up much less space than driving. It would take far more pedestrians to create the perceived amount of vehicular traffic that exists now.

Mixed Uses Invite Ruinious Uses
"Successful city districts are never dotted with junk yards, but that is not why these districts are successful. It is the other way around. They lack junk yards because they are successful."
Ruinous uses are often space-consuming, low economic uses. Vital city districts raise property values and cultivate more profitable, space intensive uses. As far as smoky manufacturing goes, the "air doesn't know about zoning boundaries." Zoning is not a good way to combat pollution, there are other, much more effective tools for that. She concludes that few legal uses "can harm a city district as much as the lack of diversity harms it."

However she does mention a few uses that are harmful: parking lots, trucking depots, gas stations, and other enterprises that, on certain streets, have the wrong scale. The first few are easy to understand, they contort space and disorganize streets, because they are so visually dominating.

I think a lot of her objections have to do with rules being made for situations where rules don't quite belong. Somebody's idea of a good idea was codified and applied to an entire municipality and it should just have been a guideline or a good idea for those that want it to take it and those that don't to leave it.  Why have a standardized environment? It would be boring.

Friday, January 27, 2012

Salvagable Parts: Six Possible Centers

Since creating mixed uses and density are the more difficult of the four generators of diversity, it is necessary to place priority on finding locations with these characteristics. Small blocks and variously aged buildings are easily retrofitted.

Downtown LaSalle
The largest of the salvageable areas, downtown LaSalle has a lot of mixed use buildings that could accommodate a good amount of density. The blocks are fairly small--even smaller if you include alleys. However most buildings are older. The new buildings built on 3rd Street lack the mixed use and density of the buildings south of 2nd. Luckily there are plenty of empty patches in the urban fabric for new construction to take place without demolishing the old!

Downtown Peru
Peru's downtown is much smaller. Yet it has two solid blocks of mixed use dense structures. There are a few newer buildings, most notably the Mirror Building. If this area expanded a bit, they might be a pretty decent place. I will refer to this area as Ninewah, since it is at the heart of the original Ninewah Addition to Peru.

Friday, January 20, 2012

Jane Jacobs: Four Generators of Diversity

 Jane Jacobs is an urban theorist, whose book, The Death and Life of Great American Cities examine the way we look at cities. She equated diversity with liveliness and a good quality of life.
"Diversity, of whatever kind, that is generated by cities rests on the fact that in cities so many people are so close together and among them contain so many different tastes, skills, needs, supplies, and bees in their bonnets."
She identified four generators of diversity:

1. Need for Primary Mixed Uses
"The district and indeed as many of its internal parts as possible, must serve more than one primary function; preferably more than two. These must insure the presence of people who go outdoors on different schedules and are in the place for different purposes, but who are able to able to use many facilities in common."
Commercial, Residential, and Religious buildings are all visible.
Lively districts should contain a mixture of uses, for example, restaurants, offices, residences, museums, garages, upscale retail, lowscale retail, industry, etc. The more different types the better, since that draws more people and more different kinds of people to that location. The connections made by these diverse groups of people form new innovations. Diverse uses also should try to ensure that there is always something going on. Diverse activities should be happening all the time. She gave an example of mealtimes, where a flurry of activity happens at mealtimes, but the rest of the day is rather dull. It is important that people mingle.  People should not be separated by the choice of  overhead walkways or alleyways that are only for deliverymen.